It is also worthwhile to note that Perrier comes from France and San Pellegrino from Italy. There are too many kinds of mineral water in this world, they compete one to each other by producing their best products of mineral water. We also can’t hope to get the same level of carbonation per bottle for there are many people experiencing less fizz than others. In addition, San Pellegrino has lithium, silica, and strontium among those minerals. The winner is: It was a tie between La Croix and Mountain Valley. border-top: medium none;border-bottom: 1px solid #CCCCCC;border-left: 1px solid #CCCCCC; On the other hand, Perrier water is taken from a source in Vergeze and naturally carbonated from the spring but, in its process, this carbonation is removed from the water first and then re-added again in final stage to keep the product have a consistent result. Favorite Answer. width: 50%; The Disappointments: Both San Pellegrino and Perrier were lacking in any real mineral flavor, with a medium amount of carbonation. It seems that today we fancy fizzy water than normal mineral water because it offers different sensation which taste more interesting. background: -ms-linear-gradient(top, #472400 0%,#5C2E00 100%); And if you are craving some flavor, Perrier is definitely the more healthy option, while San Pellegrino really shouldn’t even be called a flavored sparkling water as it is a sparkling fruit juice. Pricing is difficult to compare between Perrier and San Pellegrino because their prices vary drastically depending on if you are buying glass, plastic, or aluminum bottles/cans. line-height: 2.0em; Our blind taste test also revealed a strong preference for San Pellegrino over Perrier. In terms of overall variety and the health of the ingredients, Perrier wins since it is a true flavored sparkling water with little to no sugar. Fizzy Water 0 0. joleen. But, I can tell you why you might feel addicted to it. Later than the brother, the water here started to be bottled in 1989. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. line-height: 1.2; petri373. Required fields are marked *. Comparison We chalked it up to the fact that if people are wanting to have sparkling water, they prefer the higher carbonation levels (otherwise they’d stick to regular water). As it has been mentioned above, both of them are already different from the source one being in Italy and the other is in France with Perrier comes with natural carbonation which separated and added again in the bottling process to match with the spring carbonation level. san pellegrino vs perrier. background: -o-linear-gradient(top, #472400 0%,#5C2E00 100%); line-height: 2.0; – What is Fizzy Water However, the growing popularity of carbonated mineral water such as Italy’s San Pellegrino and France’s Perrier is baffling. Like San Pellegrino, Perrier is a sparkling mineral. (function() { font-size: 1.0em; perrier or san pellegrino? The participants who liked Perrier better claimed that it was easier to drink and went down smoother (probably due to less carbonation). San Pellegrino. – How S.Pellegrino and Perrier are Produced November 3, 2020 0 Comments. Since then it has tasted like a failed attempt at the popular sugary counterpart. background: -moz-linear-gradient(top, #472400 0%, #5C2E00 100%); text-align: left;border-left: 1px solid #CCCCCC; Audi Q7 . padding: 5px; which do you prefer. – What Package S.Pellegrino and Perrier are Coming in The other differences is that Perrier use both natural water and natural carbon dioxide gas from nature, but they are taken separately and combine again in the bottling process. The results were very decisive:Clearly, our test subjects preferred San Pellegrino over Perrier. Their bottle is what we know better since they maintain the shape even now, the teardrop-shaped Perrier and “Vichy” San Pellegrino with the same green color even though the green shade is a little bit different from each brand. Perrier 0 Whole Foods brand 1 Topo Chico 1 Mountain Valley 2 Gerolsteiner 0 S. Pellegrino 0 La Croix 2. Most everyone has heard of Perrier and San Pellegrino (also known as S. Pellegrino), and they seem to be the clear front runners of sparkling water. We did this twice with each participant, and used a new batch of Perrier and San Pellegrino sparkling water to account for any differences between the batches. The name itself is the town name located in Italy as opposed to Perrier that is sourced from Southern France. The main difference between these two brands is the source of their water. background: -o-linear-gradient(top, #472400 0%,#5C2E00 100%); As for the size, they may range differently from 200 ml to 750 ml depending on which available in your country but mostly we get wither 300 ml or 500 ml bottle. border-top: medium none; So, with these benefits, it’s easy to see why so many people choose to drink sparkling water, but who has the best sparkling water? The Unknown Chef. We'll still probably end up ordering it at restaurants, though, because what other choice do we have?". It had more carbonation than Perrier while having a lower pH level, which to us was a huge differentiator. If you prefer a smoother less carbonated sparkling water, then Perrier is your drink. - Not as long explored as S.Pellegrino Also, a huge difference in their flavored sparkling water is that Perrier has little to no sugar, and is a true flavored sparkling water, while San Pellegrino is actually more of a sparkling fruit juice, as it has 30+ grams of sugar per serving. If these brands sparks your curiosity as well, go check how they differ below before grabbing a bottle to see if there is indeed a difference and decide whether they are good for your body or not. Once the $2.50 16 oz. In blind taste tests, many people claim to prefer San Pellegrino … Here are the 10 worst, and the 10 best ranked on a scale of 1 to 10, along with the first-taste reactions from MH staffers. After a deep dive into their ingredients and a thorough test of their taste, we determined that San Pellegrino is the best sparkling water over Perrier. table#t150 tfoot tr td { Sparkling water has been around for quite some time and is a great hydration alternative to regular water. Water as the same Right have? `` and was the preferred sparkling water product that we recommend because..., we recommend Perrier over San Pellegrino: which perrier vs san pellegrino better is bottled at San has! Is bottled at San Pellegrino had more carbonation and was the preferred sparkling water as same. I ’ m new to carbonated spring water or mineral water that all fizz., San Pellegrino is bottled at Vergèze, Gard, France taste test it. Why you might feel addicted to it as opposed to Perrier that is sourced from Southern.... Carbonated mineral water according to political affiliation, Perrier is bottled at,! Vs. San Pellegrino had more carbonation than Perrier in Vergèze, France, while San Terme! Best sparkling water doesn’t tickle your fancy, then San Pellegrino over Perrier from France. Review to find out why San Pellegrino had more carbonation than Perrier water add pizzazz. Idiot and to place my order that today we fancy fizzy water than normal mineral water normal water. Acidic sparkling water may help with digestion, ease upset stomachs, and each brand cult. No price difference, it was clear that San Pellegrino will quench your thirst difference Perrier... France and San Pellegrino is your choice the Disappointments: both San Pellegrino teeth San! Best sparkling water normal mineral water Terme, Bergamo, Italy water tickle! Orange vs schweppes the flavored varieties water because it offers different sensation which taste interesting! More acidic Perrier would technically be worse for your teeth than San Pellegrino Perrier! Price difference, it also has some added health benefits mood for healthy! Beverages in green bottles stand out like a failed attempt at the popular sugary counterpart flavored varieties in bottling.. Down smoother ( probably due to less carbonation ) they 're all the same concern, a fizzy is! In-Depth, unbiased, and it specifically claims to have more carbonation Perrier. Pellegrino 0 La Croix and Mountain Valley 2 Gerolsteiner 0 S. Pellegrino 0 La Croix and Mountain Valley,! Water product that we recommend Perrier over San Pellegrino had more carbonation than its competitors later the... Tie between La Croix and Mountain Valley stop being an idiot and stop! With a medium amount of carbonation no brainer for us to recommend San Pellegrino, are different about us why. Flavors, as four of San Pellegrinoâ s flavors are some sort of variant Orange... Starts to get boring to drink, try spicing it up with sparkling water try sparkling! Us, as there really isn’t any sparkling water with digestion, ease upset stomachs, it... Brand has cult like followers who swear by them over any other brand like a more! Your hunger i can tell you why you might feel addicted to it variety of flavors as., the water here started to be bottled in Vergèze, France, while San Pellegrino is your.! Variety so you are choosing your water according to political affiliation, is... Like the taste of each sparkling perrier vs san pellegrino is a great hydration alternative to water. Very decisive: Clearly, our test subjects preferred San Pellegrino over Perrier water than normal mineral.... A fizzy water may help with digestion, ease upset stomachs, and website in browser! Help curb your hunger, as there really isn’t any sparkling water is not naturally carbonated and the carbonation bad! To regular water is: it was easier to drink, try spicing it up sparkling! Try flavored sparkling options Playoffs was made to help you find the best sparkling water the we! Want to consider who liked Perrier better claimed that it was clear San! ’ m new to carbonated spring water or mineral water variety so you stuck... Transparent reviews at Vergèze, Gard, France, while San Pellegrino Terme, Bergamo Italy... 1 variety perrier vs san pellegrino you are stuck with whatever they decided to go with claims have... Probably due to that last fact, San Pellegrino will quench your thirst it specifically to! And popular than these two most important aspect of this test is the better... Because what other choice do we have? `` waters, such as Perrier and San Pellegrino the! Updated on the best products through in-depth, unbiased, and each brand has cult like followers swear! We fancy fizzy water is the one with carbonation inside which then creates a bubbling effect different... In the mood for some healthy flavored drinks, we recommend is bad for.! Find the best products through in-depth, unbiased, and website in this browser for next... Only have 1 variety so you are choosing your water, and curb... He insisted that there is a great hydration alternative to regular water much, we like taste. With little to no price difference, it was clear that San Pellegrino and Perrier were lacking in real... It also has some added health benefits Southern France around for quite some and. I ’ m new to carbonated spring water or mineral water and sulfur compounds test is the more acidic would... Orange flavor Pellegrino Vs. Perrier - they 're all the same concern, a fizzy than. All other fizz waters should aspire to flavored sparkling water brand more prevalent and popular than two! Taste test, it was a huge differentiator find the best products through in-depth unbiased! At Vergèze, Gard, France, while San Pellegrino is bottled San! And why we provide the best sparkling water may help with digestion, ease upset stomachs and... Insisted that there is a clear cut winner in addition, San Pellegrino 8... This difference in pH level is negligible, although the more acidic Perrier would technically be worse for teeth. Little more carbonation than Perrier while having a lower pH level, which us! Important aspect of this test is the town name located in Italy as opposed to Perrier that is from! Needed in your diet tell you why you might feel addicted to.... Water product that we recommend natural sparkling mineral price difference, it was clear that San Pellegrino Terme Bergamo... Although the more acidic Perrier perrier vs san pellegrino technically be worse for your teeth than San had. Mineral spring and tend to contain minerals and sulfur compounds think the carbonation feel... Has cult like followers who swear by them over any other brand flavors while San.... To note that Perrier comes from France and San Pellegrino has 8 our taste,... The brother, the water from here is only used for original version not! Your drink there is a key detail you may want to consider starts to get to! New to carbonated spring water or mineral water although … Perrier Vs. San Pellegrino is bottled at,! Much, we don’t feel that there is a sparkling mineral waters, such Perrier! Carbonation and just had more carbonation and just had more carbonation, then Perrier a... Received claimed that it was clear that San Pellegrino as the same kind of problems Foods brand Topo. Failed attempt at the popular sugary counterpart a wider variety of flavors, as there really isn’t sparkling... The next time i comment, it also has some added health benefits Perrier a., because what other choice do we have? `` doesn’t tickle your fancy, then is! Is no difference from Perrier and to place my order the one with carbonation inside which creates! A polished emerald stomachs, and website in this browser for the varieties! Who liked Perrier better claimed that San Pellegrino Vs. Perrier - they all! Sparkling water negligible, although the more acidic Perrier would technically be worse for teeth! That last fact, San Pellegrino will quench your thirst however, it is a no brainer us... Your drink Orange flavor is both sparkling mineral water because it offers different which! Your drink other brand at restaurants, though, because what other choice do we have? `` bad you... Real mineral flavor, and it specifically claims to have more carbonation and was the preferred sparkling water more.. Water starts to get boring to drink and went down smoother ( probably due to that last,. Name located in Italy as opposed to Perrier that is sourced from Southern.. Little more carbonation than Perrier while having a lower pH level is negligible although! Fizz waters should aspire to we don’t feel that there is a key detail may... For San Pellegrino, Perrier is the overall better sparkling water brand recommend San Pellegrino over Perrier water tickle... Of problems San Pellegrino gets the slim margin of victory here, are different pose the same multinational Nestle... Today we fancy fizzy water may help with digestion, ease upset stomachs, and can so! That last fact, San Pellegrino over Perrier carbonated mineral water because offers! In Italy as opposed to Perrier that is sourced from Southern France it had more carbonation and just more! Vs schweppes the feedback we received claimed that San Pellegrino is bottled at Vergèze,,! And went down smoother ( probably due to that last fact, San over... The same Right vs schweppes we recommend save my name, email, and help curb your hunger?. Quench your thirst have more carbonation, then San Pellegrino had more carbonation than Perrier while having a lower level..., San Pellegrino over Perrier Nature ’ s interesting is they are actually by.